Every episode of Pod Save America, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
Poll Me Twice, Shame On Me
What was discussed
Trump's optimal midterm strategy3:20
- Galen Drukeassertion
Trump should end the Iran war, undo tariffs, and elevate other Republicans, but economic anger makes this strategy ineffective now.
- Nate Silverassertion
Trump should collaborate with Elon Musk to undo the war decision, but is instead grasping at straws with gimmicks.
- Clare Maloneassertion
The midterm convention forces Republicans to attend, highlighting the party's awkward struggle to define a post-Trump agenda.
Republican midterm convention dynamics7:22
- Nate Silverassertion
The convention forces reporters to chase Republicans like Mike Rogers, who decided to attend despite a tough race.
- Clare Maloneassertion
The convention is unhelpful because it keeps Trump front and center instead of letting Republicans run against him, and will pivot to anti-Democrat messaging.
JD Vance distancing from Trump9:18
- Clare Maloneassertion
JD Vance is distancing himself from Trump on Iran, reflecting a broader problem Republicans will face defining a post-Trump agenda.
Michigan Senate race dynamics16:49
- Clare Maloneassertion
Michigan displays complicated Democratic dynamics with Jewish groups not endorsing El-Sayed, highlighting internal factionalism.
- Nate Silverassertion
El-Sayed is a below-average candidate who will underperform, but Democrats have a large environmental cushion in Michigan.
- Galen Drukeassertion
The race tests whether a left activist can win in a battleground state, with recriminations likely if he loses.
Candidate quality and performance metrics42:35
- Nate Silverassertion
Data shows candidates like Ilhan Omar and Elizabeth Warren underperform generic Democrats, but talent like AOC's can offset this.
- Clare Maloneassertion
First impressions matter, and El-Sayed's leftward primary positioning makes general election moderation difficult.
Polling accuracy in primaries43:30
- Nate Silverassertion
Primary polls have a massive margin of error, with a 25-point empirical margin, making them highly uncertain compared to general elections.
- Galen Drukeassertion
The average error in a statewide primary is 13 percentage points, so polls should not be expected to be within two or three points.
Center-left political vision45:41
- Nate Silverassertion
The center-left needs a big-tent liberal vision with two major policies, like Obama's appeal to both liberals and moderates.
- Clare Maloneassertion
A successful strategy is going left on one core issue while breaking with the party on others to appear authentic.
- Galen Drukeassertion
A coherent liberal worldview can combine free markets, healthcare decoupling, and controlled legal immigration.
Rob Sand's Iowa campaign strategy53:23
- Clare Maloneassertion
Rob Sand runs above the partisan fray by being direct and pragmatic, avoiding attacks on vested interests like big ag.
Modeling methodology and data weighting1:00:46
- Nate Silverassertion
Polling importance increases near election day, and fundraising weights are determined empirically via multivariate regression on past data.
- John Lovettassertion
The model qualitatively weights dependent data and handles randomization in simulations, but the empirical basis for weighting is unclear.
Modeling unpredictability and overfitting1:08:06
- Nate Silverassertion
Unpredictability is predictable, and models must avoid overfitting by incorporating political knowledge about polarization.
- John Lovettopinion
Modeling a unique event run only once is philosophically difficult, as it tries to account for unknowable future events.
Every episode of Pod Save America, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
More from Pod Save America
Automated summaries of what was said on each show — not claims by DailyDossier and not independently verified.