What the sports shows argued about today, and who took which side.

Giants quarterback Jaxson Dart will undergo surgery and is out for the remainder of the season, a devastating blow to a franchise already struggling with quarterback instability. Backup Jameis Winston's production does not translate to wins, and the offense was built around Dart's mobility. The team is projected to finish around six or seven wins, with some suggesting they should acquire a mobile quarterback like Joe Milton to salvage the scheme, though bringing in a new quarterback mid-season is difficult because they must learn a complex offense without a preseason. Despite the current knee injury, the Giants should still trust Dart as their franchise quarterback because he has shown growth in protecting himself and his playing style is worth the risk.

SOURCES  1 · 2

The Bears may start third-string quarterback Case Keenum against the Eagles due to injuries to Caleb Williams and Tyson Bagent. Analysts believe Chicago still has a chance if they lean on the run game and Keenum manages the offense effectively, though Keenum has not thrown 20 or more air yards since before COVID, reinforcing the expectation that Chicago will run the ball heavily. Ben Johnson's offense can succeed with Keenum playing point guard and distributing to playmakers, though it will be his first game without a top pick or starting QB.

SOURCES  1

The Bengals' defense has shown significant improvement through two games, holding opponents under 17 points and forcing turnovers. Additions like Dexter Lawrence have made a major impact, making the defense completely different. Joe Burrow is on the level with Josh Allen and Patrick Mahomes, and with a defense, the Bengals are a weapon of mass destruction, though they need to prove themselves against tougher competition before being placed in the top AFC tier with the Bills and Chiefs.

SOURCES  1

Shane Steichen's overtime play-calling against the Chiefs is heavily criticized, arguing that running the ball and settling for a field goal instead of aggressively pursuing a touchdown was a fatal mistake that cost the Colts the game. The decision was a clear error, and there is no pushback from the panel on that point.

SOURCES  1

The Steelers' offense has struggled through two games, averaging under 250 yards and scoring only three points in Week Two. The team is in huge trouble due to poor offensive production, an aging Aaron Rodgers, and a lack of receiving options. However, patience is warranted because Rodgers and McCarthy are still figuring out their second iteration together, and the team has too much talent to remain this bad, with a history of overcoming early struggles and finishing strong.

SOURCES  1

The Texans are 0-2 with a struggling defense and no run game. The defense has given up explosive plays, and CJ Stroud is the only thing keeping them competitive. Patience is warranted because the division is weak, the team rallied from 0-3 last year, and Stroud is playing well while the defense underperforms, though the defense will likely improve.

SOURCES  1