Every episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
The Double Life of Scott Peterson: Justice For Laci and Conner — Ep. 5 | MK Confidential
What was discussed
Jurors inspect Scott Peterson's boat0:36
- Megyn Kellyassertion
Jurors tested the boat's stability by shifting weight, but the judge halted the experiment after the defense objected.
- Greg Baratlasopinion
The rusting pliers and standing water in the boat do not fit Scott's meticulous nature, suggesting it was purchased for a single purpose.
Prosecution closing argument focuses on location4:22
- Rick Distasioassertion
Scott Peterson was the only person known to be at the exact location where Laci and Conner's bodies washed ashore at the time they went missing. The motive for the murders was the impending birth of Conner, not the affair with Amber Frey.
Defense closing argument attacks police investigation6:29
- Mark Geragosassertion
The Modesto police decided Scott was guilty immediately and then looked for evidence to fit that conclusion. Being a terrible husband or a liar is not proof of murder.
Juror Francis Gorman removed for internet research7:35
- Megyn Kellyassertion
Francis Gorman conducted independent research on her computer despite the judge's repeated warnings not to investigate the case.
Foreman Gregory Jackson removed over safety concerns9:37
- Mark Geragosassertion
The foreman was removed because he felt threatened and believed his desired verdict would not fit community expectations.
- Mark Geragosopinion
The judge should have removed the threatening juror, a doctor and lawyer, rather than the foreman.
- Gregory Jacksonassertion
His ability to remain fair and impartial was compromised, and he felt unsafe due to hostile remarks from other jurors.
Jury convicts Scott Peterson of two murders2:10
- Megyn Kellyassertion
The jury unanimously convicted Scott Peterson of two murders within hours of restarting deliberations for the second time.
- Jurorsassertion
Scott Peterson showed no emotion or reaction when the guilty verdict was read.
Sharon Rocha's emotional penalty phase testimony15:56
- Sharon Rochaassertion
Divorce is always an option, not murder.
- Garth Stapleyopinion
Sharon Rocha's sobbing and screaming at Scott deeply affected everyone observing the testimony.
Jury sentences Scott Peterson to death17:16
- Megyn Kellyassertion
The jury fixed the penalty at death after deliberating for over eight hours across three days.
- Rochelle Nieceassertion
Scott Peterson should look people in the face when they are talking to him.
- Mike Bellmieriassertion
Prison is Scott Peterson's new home, and it is illegal to kill your wife and child in California.
California Supreme Court overturns death sentence20:49
- Megyn Kellyassertion
The California Supreme Court overturned the death sentence because Judge Deluca improperly dismissed prospective jurors without asking if they could follow the law.
- Mark Geragosassertion
Jurors cannot be dismissed simply for opposing the death penalty; the judge must ask if they can follow the law.
Rochelle Niece's juror misconduct and letters25:39
- Megyn Kellyassertion
Rochelle Niece wrote 17 letters to Scott Peterson and failed to disclose a prior restraining order on her juror questionnaire.
- Mark Geragosopinion
Rochelle Niece was a problematic juror who wrote letters to Scott and celebrated the conviction in a wild manner.
- Rochelle Nieceassertion
She did not think about her prior restraining order case when filling out the questionnaire because it was dropped and went nowhere.
- Judgeassertion
Rochelle Niece's false answers on the questionnaire were due to misunderstanding, not bias, so a new trial was denied.
Innocence Project seeks new evidence testing28:39
- Megyn Kellyassertion
The Innocence Project requested retesting of a mattress and duct tape, but the judge only allowed access to van reports and duct tape testing. A private lab reported trace amounts of possible male DNA on the mattress fabric in 2019.
Mark Geragos supports new trial for Scott Peterson30:48
- Mark Geragosopinion
There was willful suppression of evidence, and it makes no sense for prosecutors to fight so hard against putting the case to rest.
Families maintain opposing views on guilt31:43
- Sharon Rochaassertion
Scott Peterson is guilty, and that is final.
- Lee and Jackie Petersonassertion
Scott Peterson is innocent.
- Amber Freyassertion
She was relieved she would not have to testify again, though she would if required.
Every episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
More from The Megyn Kelly Show
- AI Regulation Debate Explodes, Congressman Survives Lake Landing, U.S. Open Champs: AM Update 9/14
- "The Double Life of Scott Peterson": The FULL MK Confidential Series
- ALARMING Comments From Female Lindsay Clancy Jurors, Shock Elizabeth Holmes Doc, and Frank Turek on One Year Since Charlie Kirk | Ep. 1394
Automated summaries of what was said on each show — not claims by DailyDossier and not independently verified.