Every episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
The Double Life of Scott Peterson: Defending Scott Peterson — Ep. 4 | MK Confidential
Mark Geragos maintains that Scott Peterson is innocent and that the prosecution's case relied on circumstantial evidence, media bias, and mishandled forensic details rather than concrete proof.
What was discussed
Geragos's early media defense of Scott Peterson0:00
- Mark Geragosassertion
Scott Peterson is not guilty and lacks the capability to commit the murders.
- Megyn Kellyassertion
Geragos initially criticized the case framing but later said he may have succumbed to media buzz.
Peterson family hires Geragos despite warnings6:38
- Mark Geragosassertion
He was convinced of Scott Peterson's innocence after meeting him and took the case despite widespread warnings.
- Lee Petersonassertion
They hired Geragos because he was defending Scott on TV, despite the high cost.
Public and juror bias against Peterson19:32
- Mark Geragosassertion
The public and jury pool were overwhelmingly biased against Peterson, creating a hostile trial environment.
Prosecution timeline challenged by computer login25:21
- Mark Geragosassertion
The Christmas Eve computer login proved Lacy was alive after the prosecution's initial timeline, forcing them to adjust.
- Rick Distasoassertion
The exact time of death is less important than proving Scott committed the murder.
Detective Brocchini's redacted report35:21
- Mark Geragosassertion
Brocchini's redaction was part of a broader pattern of evidence being withheld or minimized.
- Al Brocchiniassertion
He removed the line because another detective had directly interviewed the witness and included it in his own report.
Boat demonstration excluded from evidence38:31
- Mark Geragosassertion
The judge wrongly excluded a boat demonstration that would have shown the prosecution's theory was implausible.
Duct tape detail added by detective42:38
- Mark Geragosassertion
Brocchini fabricated the duct tape detail, undermining his credibility and the prosecution's case.
Mitochondrial DNA hair evidence disputed43:33
- Constance Fisherassertion
The hair found in the boat matched Lacy's mitochondrial DNA profile, which is rare in Modesto.
- Dr. William Shieldsassertion
The DNA match is less significant than claimed, potentially as common as 1 in 9 people.
- Mark Geragosassertion
The hair evidence was mishandled, with one hair becoming two, suggesting contamination or fabrication.
Amber Fry tapes damage Peterson's credibility46:16
- Greg Baratlasassertion
The tapes showed Scott lying and acting coldly, which convinced him of Scott's guilt.
- Pat Harrisassertion
The tapes alone were damning enough to sink the defense.
Defense expert's fetal dating challenged47:13
- Dr. Charles Marchassertion
Connor died on December 29th, meaning Lacy was alive days after Christmas Eve.
- Dr. Gregory Devoreassertion
Ultrasound measurements indicate Connor died on December 23rd or 24th, aligning with the prosecution's timeline.
Uncalled eyewitnesses for the defense49:31
- Mark Geragosassertion
The uncalled eyewitnesses were unnecessary because their accounts were already admitted through police testimony.
- Matt Daltonassertion
He does not know why Geragos never called the eyewitnesses he found.
Geragos's regret over lack of televised trial57:02
- Mark Geragosopinion
Televising the trial would have debunked public misconceptions and shown the prosecution's case was weak.
Every episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
More from The Megyn Kelly Show
- AI Regulation Debate Explodes, Congressman Survives Lake Landing, U.S. Open Champs: AM Update 9/14
- "The Double Life of Scott Peterson": The FULL MK Confidential Series
- ALARMING Comments From Female Lindsay Clancy Jurors, Shock Elizabeth Holmes Doc, and Frank Turek on One Year Since Charlie Kirk | Ep. 1394
Automated summaries of what was said on each show — not claims by DailyDossier and not independently verified.