Every episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
The Double Life of Scott Peterson: The Alternate Theories — Ep. 3 | MK Confidential
What was discussed
Diane Jackson's van sighting on Christmas Eve0:00
- Diane Jacksonassertion
She saw three men and a van outside 516 Covina at 11:40 a.m. on Christmas Eve, and they noticed her as she drove by.
- Megyn Kellyassertion
Police hypnotized Jackson to draw out details, but under California law, this effectively ended her usefulness as a witness.
Multiple witnesses report strange van near Peterson home4:07
- Megyn Kellyassertion
At least five people reported a strange van in the neighborhood around the time Laci disappeared, with several sightings on Covina at the same hour Scott was loading his truck.
Defense investigator Matt Dalton examines van and witness accounts4:34
- Matt Daltonassertion
He investigated the van sightings and interviewed six witnesses who saw a pregnant woman walking a golden retriever, but none ever testified.
Homer and Helen Maldonado's sighting of pregnant woman6:24
- Homer Maldonadoassertion
He saw a very pregnant woman walking a golden retriever near Covina on Christmas Eve, later identified her as Laci Peterson, and reported it to police and her brother.
Vivian Mitchell and Diana Campos witness accounts7:19
- Vivian Mitchellassertion
She saw a pregnant woman walking a golden retriever from her window at 10:30 a.m. on Christmas Eve.
- Diana Camposassertion
She saw a pregnant woman walking a golden retriever with two men following, one of whom shouted at the dog to shut up.
Liora Garcia and Russell Graybill's observations9:07
- Liora Garciaassertion
She saw a vehicle with a woman's coat caught in the door speed away, later recalling it was a white van with a wooden rack.
- Russell Graybillassertion
He delivered mail to the Petersons between 10:35 and 10:50 a.m. on December 24th and noted the side gate was open and the dog did not bark.
Dispute over mailman's account and missing evidence10:53
- Karen Serviceassertion
She personally put the dog back in the Petersons' yard at 10:18 a.m., closing the gate behind her.
- Megyn Kellyassertion
The mailman's report was lost in paperwork and only found years later, so the jury never heard about the open gate or the dog that did not bark.
Medina burglary and conflicting timelines11:57
- Susan Medinaassertion
She found her home at 516 Covina burglarized on the evening of December 26th.
- Stephen Toddassertion
He claimed he went over the fence at 3:00 a.m. on December 27th.
- Donald Pierceassertion
He said Stephen came to him for help moving the safe on December 26th.
- Detective John Buellerassertion
He stated the burglary occurred on December 25th and 26th, with the safe taken on the 26th.
- Modesto Police Departmentassertion
They settled on December 26th as the date of the burglary and announced it had nothing to do with Laci Peterson's disappearance.
Burglars' connection to Laci Peterson disappearance12:25
- Stephen Toddassertion
He told police he had nothing to do with 'the missing woman with the baby.'
- Lieutenant Xavier Aponteassertion
He claimed an inmate said Laci walked up during the burglary and was threatened, but later walked back his story.
- Modesto Police Departmentassertion
They dispute Aponte's account and say there are no reports showing anyone from the department was ever in contact with him.
Destruction of burglary interview tapes19:27
- Prosecutorsassertion
They said the burglary was solved and the evidence was destroyed as part of routine procedure.
- Scott Peterson's defenseassertion
They argued that in a capital case, evidence potentially connected to an alternate theory should have been preserved.
Burning van found near Peterson home19:55
- Modesto fire investigatorassertion
He ruled the burning van arson and found faint evidence of possible blood on a mattress in the back.
- State Department of Justice labassertion
They found no blood on the mattress.
Police dismiss alternate theories and witness reliability21:24
- Detective John Buellerassertion
He dismissed the van sightings and burglary connection, citing witness unreliability and the rarity of a property criminal turning into an abductor. He doubted Laci was walking that morning due to her physical condition and noted other pregnant women in the neighborhood.
Scott Peterson's arrest and suspicious behavior26:33
- Detective Al Brocchiniassertion
He described Scott Peterson having orange hair and a goatee at the time of arrest.
- Torrey Pines golf club managerassertion
He said Scott Peterson did not have a tee time, but his father Lee did.
Every episode of The Megyn Kelly Show, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
More from The Megyn Kelly Show
- AI Regulation Debate Explodes, Congressman Survives Lake Landing, U.S. Open Champs: AM Update 9/14
- "The Double Life of Scott Peterson": The FULL MK Confidential Series
- ALARMING Comments From Female Lindsay Clancy Jurors, Shock Elizabeth Holmes Doc, and Frank Turek on One Year Since Charlie Kirk | Ep. 1394
Automated summaries of what was said on each show — not claims by DailyDossier and not independently verified.