Every episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
3 & Out - CFB Week 1 Reaction: Western Michigan-Michigan, Clemson-LSU, Boise State-Oregon
John Middlekauff repeatedly argues that modern college football is a transactional, mercenary sport where adaptability, aggressive roster building via NIL and the portal, and coaching mastery at smaller programs determine success, while traditional loyalty and outdated approaches lead to decline.
Briefed in the Sports Talk edition of Tuesday, 08 September 2026
What was discussed
Western Michigan's overturned win against Michigan4:21
- John Middlekauffopinion
The overturned win is a travesty that robbed Western Michigan players of a seminal, life-changing moment they would have carried forever. The Big Ten's video evidence for the reversal is hard to take seriously and looks shady.
Bryce Underwood's poor performance for Michigan17:44
- John Middlekauffassertion
Bryce Underwood looked worse than last year, is inaccurate on critical throws, and lacks the dynamic athleticism of elite college quarterbacks.
- John Middlekauffspeculation
Underwood will likely transfer to another school next year, and Michigan has a massive quarterback problem.
Lane Kiffin's coaching style and LSU's dominance32:08
- John Middlekauffassertion
Lane Kiffin thrives in chaos and is now an elite coach who builds incredible rosters and staffs. LSU's performance showed overwhelming speed, violence, and explosion, looking like one of Saban's peak teams. Dabo Swinney's refusal to adapt to the transactional, mercenary nature of modern college football is causing his brand and program to diminish.
Boise State's competitive culture against Oregon38:32
- John Middlekauffassertion
Boise State has a rare, quiet confidence and a unique blend of schematic intelligence and physical toughness that lets them consistently compete with elite programs. Boise has Oregon's number historically, winning three of five matchups over 20 years, including close games in the NIL era.
Indiana's rapid rise via NIL and the transfer portal54:41
- John Middlekauffassertion
Indiana has benefited more than any program from the NIL era by aggressively buying established college players from other schools. Indiana transformed overnight from the worst program in Division I history into a legitimate football school with NFL-caliber talent.
Miami's quarterback upgrade and championship potential56:20
- John Middlekauffassertion
Darian Mensa is a massive upgrade over Carson Beck, creating a dynamic Miami offense reminiscent of the Mahomes-Hill Chiefs era.
- John Middlekauffspeculation
Miami is now a clear championship contender with this quarterback upgrade, though winning a title remains difficult.
Arch Manning's improvement and Texas quarterback rankings58:05
- John Middlekauffassertion
Arch Manning looked dramatically improved in Week 1, making Middlekauff hesitant to dismiss him from top quarterback rankings.
- John Middlekauffspeculation
The upcoming game against Ohio State will be a real test to determine if Manning's improvement is sustainable.
Bob Chesney's emergence as a top coach at UCLA1:02:09
- John Middlekauffassertion
Bob Chesney is a big-time coach who mastered his craft at smaller programs and delivered a dominant road win over Cal with UCLA.
- John Middlekauffspeculation
Chesney's structure and coaching will help quarterback Nico develop into a high NFL draft pick.
Every episode of The Herd with Colin Cowherd, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
More from The Herd with Colin Cowherd
- Joe and Jada - NFL Week 1 Reaction: Giants UPSET Cowboys on SNF, Bills OUTLAST Texans in Thriller, Ravens DOMINATE Colts
- The Richard Sherman Podcast - NFL Week 1 REACTION: Giants UPSET Cowboys, Bills vs. Texans, Bears Score 59 & Myles Garrett Injury
- Colin Cowherd Podcast - Bears Light It Up, Packers Cause For Concern, Epic Texas Comeback vs. Ohio State, Josh Allen Dominant
Automated summaries of what was said on each show — not claims by DailyDossier and not independently verified.