Every episode of Judging Freedom, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
LtCOL. Tony Shaffer : Is War in Ukraine Nearing Its End?
LtCol. Tony Shaffer repeatedly argues that the U.S. should have remained a neutral mediator in Ukraine rather than supplying weapons or intelligence, as the conflict serves no American strategic interest, depletes U.S. military resources, and ignores the immutable historical security requirements of Russia. He contends that American involvement is driven by the military-industrial complex and neocon fantasies of regime change, while the only viable resolution is Ukrainian neutrality as a buffer state.
What was discussed
U.S. interests in Ukraine conflict1:43
- LtCol. Tony Shafferassertion
The U.S. has minimal strategic interest in Ukraine, and continued weapon supply benefits the military-industrial complex while depleting U.S. resources.
Root causes and resource competition in war3:43
- LtCol. Tony Shafferassertion
The war is primarily driven by competition over newly discovered gas and oil reserves in the region, not by liberation narratives. Supplying high-tech weapons to Ukraine has significantly depleted U.S. reserves, endangering the ability to meet other strategic objectives.
Intelligence support and co-belligerency5:25
- LtCol. Tony Shafferopinion
U.S. intelligence agencies are providing essential GPS and targeting data for Ukrainian strikes, but this proxy support does not legally make the U.S. a co-belligerent.
- Foreign Minister Lavrovclip
The U.S. acts as a co-belligerent by providing intelligence that enables Ukrainian attacks on Russian territory.
Diplomatic shifts and neocon influence8:57
- LtCol. Tony Shafferassertion
A diplomatic agreement from the Alaska summit has been discarded due to hardline shifts by figures like Marco Rubio, prolonging the war. Neocons are falsely portraying limited Ukrainian deep strikes as winning the war to pressure Putin, ignoring that conventional victory is impossible.
Kissinger's neutrality thesis12:14
- Henry Kissinger (played clip)clip
Ukraine must not be an outpost against either side but should function as a bridge to ensure its survival and thrive.
- LtCol. Tony Shafferassertion
Neutrality is the only viable path for Ukraine because Russia's historical trauma from repeated invasions necessitates a buffer zone it will never relinquish.
NATO force capability assessment16:10
- LtCol. Tony Shafferopinion
NATO lacks independent combat power and relies entirely on U.S. logistics and command, making European threats against Russia illogical.
- Vladimir Putin (played clip)clip
NATO is gradually seeping into the area, deploying new weapon systems and ramping up tensions that pose serious threats to Russia.
- LtCol. Tony Shafferspeculation
Putin's warnings about a NATO threat are primarily intended for domestic audiences, as intelligence shows NATO lacks the capacity for a decisive offensive.
Iran policy and military strain20:59
- LtCol. Tony Shafferassertion
Trump's low approval stems from bad advice on Iran and a reliance on decapitation strikes sold by Benjamin Netanyahu. The U.S. Navy is under severe strain due to an abnormally high combat tempo, evidenced by supply issues and personnel stress on the USS Abraham Lincoln.
Every episode of Judging Freedom, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.
Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.
More from Judging Freedom
Automated summaries of what was said on each show — not claims by DailyDossier and not independently verified.