Every episode of Judging Freedom, briefed the morning after, with up to nine more shows in one daily email.

Free for 30 days. No card needed. $4.99 a month after.

COL. Lawrence Wilkerson : Is the US a Republic or an Empire?

12 August 2026 · 27m

Wilkerson repeatedly argues that the United States has become an overextended empire whose imperial reach—hundreds of overseas bases, depleted munitions, and simultaneous conflicts in Ukraine, Iran, and potentially the Pacific—has outstripped its actual military, industrial, and diplomatic capacity. He contends this gap between imperial pretension and real power, combined with the absence of genuine US diplomacy and European allies' mistaken belief that Washington still stands firmly behind them, is pushing the world toward dangerous escalation in both Europe and the Middle East.

What was discussed

US motives for remaining in Ukraine3:43

Wilkerson argues Trump is not really driving Ukraine policy but is 'on automatic pilot,' distracted by a more urgent political war in Southwest Asia. He frames continued US involvement as part of an inexorable global power shift away from Western empires toward a China-led bloc that now includes North Korea, possibly Iran, Turkey, India, and Russia, a shift that Biden (pushed by Blinken and Sullivan) deepened using sanctions and military force.

Collapse of US-Russia diplomacy7:24

Wilkerson asserts there is currently no meaningful diplomacy between Washington and Moscow, and none in Southwest Asia either, despite having a Secretary of State who holds multiple overlapping roles but doesn't practice diplomacy. He says real negotiation lapsed once Trump handed the process to the Europeans, who he claims have reverted to 1930s-style recklessness.

Risk of Russian strikes on NATO targets8:17

Wilkersonspeculation
Russia will pinpoint-strike NATO assets in Ukraine and may escalate to a NATO country like Lithuania if that fails
Putin (clip)clip
NATO is encroaching on Russia's borders with new weapons systems that pose serious threats, while Russia seeks cooperation with China, India and others on Arctic shipping routes

NATO munitions shortage under General Grynkewich10:17

Wilkersonassertion
Munitions depleted by Southwest Asia and Israel operations threaten Europe's defense against Russia
Napolitanoassertion
Conditions on the USS Abraham Lincoln are so bad there have been seven suicide attempts

NATO membership as a non-negotiable sticking point14:07

Napolitanoassertion
E3 and Zelensky maintain NATO membership is required for any settlement
Wilkersonopinion
Putin would never accept NATO membership for Ukraine under any circumstances, even at gunpoint

Trump's trapped position after Iran conflict17:05

Wilkerson says Trump has very few options to salvage what he characterizes as a loss in the 13-day Iran conflict, given devastating approval polling ahead of the midterms. He argues Trump is politically and personally unwilling to 'eat crow' and is effectively trapped, with no clear path out absent a diplomatic corps the administration currently lacks.

Iranian unity against US and Israel19:21

Wilkerson describes Iran as an ethnically diverse state (roughly 51-52% Persian, with other nationalities and a Jewish population) that has been fused by recent conflict into a body resolved to fight the US and Israel to the death. He argues no air campaign in history has broken resolve rather than hardening it, and Iranians see no prospect of change in Israel's stance and view the US as fully aligned with Israel under the current president.

US as republic versus empire20:17

Asked directly whether the US is a republic or an empire, Wilkerson answers unequivocally 'Empire,' tracing the shift from the Great White Fleet and Spanish-American War through slowdowns in the interwar years to a post-WWII peak when the US held 51% of world GDP and overwhelming military production. He argues the imperial impulse, checked temporarily by the Soviet Union and briefly restrained by George H.W. Bush, took over decisively after Bush's defeat (which Wilkerson attributes partly to AIPAC support for Clinton), ultimately killing the Republic much as Octavian's consolidation ended the Roman Republic.

Contested

Disputed count of US overseas military bases23:38

Napolitano (citing Phil Giraldi)assertion
US overseas military installations number closer to 1,100, costing $75-80 billion annually
Wilkersonassertion
The true figure is between 730 and 750 bases using stricter criteria, and China has around 11-12 overseas bases, not one

US capacity for simultaneous two-front war25:04

Napolitano asks whether the US could fight Russia in Europe and China in the Pacific simultaneously given it struggles even with Ukraine and Iran. Wilkerson flatly answers 'not on your life,' arguing the US lacks the industrial base and would need roughly a decade to build one capable of such conflicts, citing a Grumman factory that received over $500 million in Army funding yet has barely produced ammunition.